Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Busted for being opaque

Corporate Responsibility Magazine shines a light on the Russell 1,000's least transparent companies.

The Black List details 30 companies for whom zero points of relevant data can be found to compare their transparency to that of colleagues on the Russell 1000 list of large-cap firms.

These companies are saying nada about things like climate change performance or broader environmental performance. The issue is bigger than the 30 companies on the list. 161 companies did not even have basic disclosure about their employee benefit programs.

The magazine approaches this situation from a corporate governance/investor relations perspective. Their audience is the corporate executive charged with maintaining good "corporate responsibility."

In the past, avoiding disclosure may have been a smart way to dodge controversy, oversight or unwelcome attention. Now choosing to not be transparent has its own cost. Remember that the next time you venture into an Abercrombie & Fitch store.

Tuesday, April 6, 2010

Yelp steps into the sunshine

Yelp just announced two substantial moves to eliminate the controversy brewing around alleged linkage between retailer advertising support and review quality.

The company is making it possible to see how their review filter works and will even show you the reviews that have been filtered. They are also eliminating the "Favorite Review" feature. Why you see what you see on Yelp just got a lot more transparent.

In retrospect, these changes are actually product improvements. Better information and less fog obscuring motives. For a company built on the idea of using consumer feedback as a weapon to reward and punish marketers, it's ironic they took this long to act on the input they were receiving themselves.

Our natural reaction as passionate, competitive marketers is often to try and argue with the public when we feel they misunderstand our company or actions. That knee-jerk reaction immediately puts us in an adversarial role with consumers. It's hard to pull out of the ping-pong match once things escalate.

At some point perhaps Yelp realized the angry hoards might have a point - maybe they could actually improve their product by making it more transparent. On the other hand, Yelp may view these recent steps as necessary concessions - conceding they could never argue the social media beast into submission. Either way, they made the right decision. Chalk one up for the meritocracy.

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Time traveling

I want to share an amusing peek at the future of traditional advertising agencies.

The Last Advertising Agency On Earth from FITC on Vimeo.

The joke has been told before but this rendition nails a real truth - fewer and fewer consumers are influenced by blunt force attempts at persuasion. If not avoided or ignored altogether, traditional advertising rarely delivers the influence conveyed when one's peers weigh-in on the merits of a product or company via social media or in person.

Many agencies ironically miss the point and assume they simply need to migrate to newer, digital communication channels. The transformation underway is not analogous to adding a department as agencies did during the mid-century transition from radio to TV. To be sure, "ads" will still be around to do things like rally enthusiasts and announce new products. But agencies will be distinguished by the ideas they bring that materially improve the customer experience or enable brand evangelists to share their convictions.

We're coming full-circle back to an era where people rely on word-of-mouth and reputation to make purchase decisions. Technology will make it easier and better than ever but I think marketing in 2020 may work a lot more like marketing in 1820 than the way it does today. That's good for (good) brands and good for consumers. I predict a buyer's market for slightly used Foosball tables.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Who will be the Southwest Airlines of car rental?

I saw yet another article today on ways brands extract revenue from customers with occasionally clever but more often blunt force add-on fees and charges.

Elizabeth Olson of The New York Times illustrates the recent escalation occurring in one particularly brutal category in her story, The rental car squeeze. Being charged $13 a gallon to refill the tank after dropping off your car (yes, this happened in Maryland) may generate a ton of cash in the short term but it can't help your brand. Not surprisingly, the percentage of dissatisfied travelers has nearly doubled from 12% to 21% in the last six years according to J. D. Power and Associates' annual Car Rental Experiences survey.

This is not big news to anyone who has rented a car in the last six years. What is newsworthy is the inability of any brand to leverage the brewing customer revulsion. Twenty one percent of the market represents a ripe opportunity. A tactic like Guaranteed, out the door pricing at the time of booking would be a game changer. It could also help reverse an increasingly adversarial relationship with at least one car rental brand. Does this sound risky? Fortunately, a very similar approach has succeeded wildly just one floor up from the rental counters.

Southwest Airlines is arguably the sole differentiated brand in the airline category. They have customer loyalty scores that are off the chart. So is their valuation when compared to the competition. Part of the Southwest appeal is their determination to not stick it to customers with add-on fees or similar "gotcha tactics."

It's time for a rental car executive to take the escalator up to ticketing to see how a successful travel category marketer delivers superior value for shareholders by making customer satisfaction (not short-term revenue enhancement) job #1.

Thursday, February 25, 2010

Toyota: doomed by its own culture?

I've resisted posting on the Toyota mess up to this point feeling that mainstream media may be piling-on a bit. The debacle is not going away. It seems a new embarrassment for the company surfaces roughly once a week.

A recent article in Automotive News by James Treece sheds new light on the culture inside Toyota and how that may be the root cause of the company's troubles. Treece spent 22 years living and reporting on the auto industry in Japan and brings firsthand knowledge of the situation.

Treece's article, while a bit inside baseball, paints a clear picture. Toyota's insular, secretive culture drove their attempts to stifle early safety concerns rather than openly vet and address them. Initiatives to suppress the damage by playing it down with the media, strong-arming regulators and what appear to be partial technical fixes have caused the biggest brand image backfire in modern marketing history.

Toyota rode one attribute, "quality" to the top of the automotive category. That's gone now. We won't know for years if they will be able to reclaim it. I'm not sure their snazzy styling or impressive handling will carry the day in the absence of the quality gene. The irony of Toyota defaulting on it's core equity is not lost on owners of Toyota vehicles.

What's missing at Toyota is the ability to be open and transparent internally and with the public. A transparent corporate culture is not a "nice to have" or a fashionable marketing trend. It's an essential means for earning the public trust. The modern marketplace rewards brands that behave with integrity. It punishes those that demonstrate they are not trustworthy. As a Toyota owner, I feel the sting every time I turn the key.

Friday, January 29, 2010

Walkin' the talk


Fast Company today details 11 Ways That Walmart Is Changing Retail -- for Good with respect to sustainable business practices. These are the same 11 ways Walmart is differentiating itself from most other big box retailers by demonstrating extraordinary social integrity. Not surprisingly, these are also the 11 ways they will probably save significant money over the long run.

Perhaps a better title for this article might be "11 ways Walmart won't have to compete on price." It's a fun slide show worth a few minutes of your time. Last post on Walmart for a while. I promise.

Thursday, January 21, 2010

Attention shoppers: Zero landfill corn chips are now available in aisle nine.

Great article by Kate Rockwood in the new Fast Company on Walmart's Sustainability Index.

What caught my eye was a quote from the Walmart SVP of Sustainability, Matt Kistler. He said of this initiative, "it is creating a new level of competition in ways that, historically manufacturers have not competed." Kistler went on to confirm that high-scoring products will earn preferential treatment -- and likely more shelf space -- in Walmart stores.

There. It's official. In addition to how well your product does what its supposed to do and how much it costs, there will soon be a third horse in the marketing race - the impact of the product (and company that makes it) on our planet and society. Shoppers won't be at the mercy of "greened-up" packaging or vague sustainability claims thanks to this quantified and verified index.

Will a killer carbon footprint rating trump a super Sunday supplement coupon offer? We'll have to wait a little longer to find out but thanks to Walmart's clout, it looks like this is really going to happen.

Read the article here.